This is the access page for an archive of forum entries. The forum iteslf is no longer available for new content. New social based chat is available on the club Facebook group.
Giant Defy 0 2016 Spec info For James Gatrell
Good afternoon James
I noticed you put you were in the market for a new bike at around £1000 value and were looking closely at the Giant Defy 0 2016 model?
I have just had a look at this spec and its not too bad to be fair - it certainly ranks as up there with the best of a bad bunch.
The frame is bog std alloy which is fairly common from the mass market producers at this point and it even has Ultegra levers and rear mech but it seems these upgrades have been done at the expense of cheap 451 deep drop 57mm brakes (usually only found on touring or winter bikes - is that what you want?), a cheap Shimano 500 compact chainset (oem version around Sora level) and cheap Giant own brand alloy bars, stem, seatpost, saddle.
The finishing kit combo of an own brand is fairly common at this price to keep costs down but I was rather surprised that they have specced cheap own brand hubs, rims and tyres for the wheelset on offer.
Not a week goes by where we don't have some unfortunate customer who has Bontrager (Trek) or Specialised or other "own brand" wheels in with some form of problem. The issue is they are usually heavy and give a dead riding feel when compared to proper Shimano or Campag wheels and when it comes to servicing they are fitted with non standard parts which means they are usually dead stock once anything goes wrong.
About a dozen of the WV have had our new Carbone SR full carbon bikes at a similar price point with a much higher overall spec with ALL parts from proper recognised branded established component manufacturers within the cycle industry.
What's more we offer a free custom fit service and actually build the bike for you, all included in the prices we quote.
I don't think it would hurt to pop in and see us for a chat or speak to some of the club who have all bought them and been delighted with them over the last 6 months.
Maybe see or speak to you soon James
.............and of course we do cyclescheme and part ex so you can have the best of both worlds................
Hi James ,Spending around £1000 on a Giant you’ll get value for money for an Aluminium bike that’s off the peg. Depending on what your using it for its a good starter bike but you may find after a very short time you’ll want to upgrade. I started with a Giant OCR compact which is now over 9yrs old and now my winter bike. For the money your looking at spending you could get an entry level Carbone complete bike with much better spec than the Giant ie, Wheels, Group set ,Seat post, Stem and bars from Dave Hinde Racing. A few in the club have the SR Carbone bike from Dave /Jim and we all agree its great value for money and the best thing the bike will be made to measure for you, so if your planning at putting a few miles in you’ll need to be comfortable.